View Single Post
Old 12-10-2003, 04:23 PM   #7 (permalink)
Missy
 
Posts:
Default Re: Green card revoked, now what UPDATE and question

Hi again,

My brother tells me now that both he and my father won their green cards in
a lottery. Since my brother has:

a) lived outside of the US for periods longer than one year and
b) let his card expire

is there any point in him trying to go before an immigration judge? I keep
telling him to drop it and move on, consider it a hard lesson learned, but
he and my father seem to think there is some loophole he can get through.
He thinks that a judge will look at his case and say "Aw, hell, you're a
nice guy, sure, here's your card back" It's a lost cause, right? No way in
hell will he be granted a new card, right?

Thanks again

"Missy" <> wrote in message
news:jkPzb.12826$...
    > Here's the story:
    > My dad got his green card years ago, and sponsored my brother, who moved
to
    > the US (From Canada)
    > My brother never bothered to look into what he had to do in order to keep
    > said green card once he had it
    > My brother would stay in the US for anywhere from 2-20 months, come back
to
    > Canada for a similar amount of time, then go back to the US
    > My brother never worked in the US
    > Last April, his card was up for renewal, he went to the office, where they
    > promptly took it back, saying he shouldn't have had one in the first
place,
    > he isn't supposed to be going to and fro (US to Canada) either, and he is
    > unemployed
    > A week ago, he came here for a visit, and when he showed up at the airport
    > to go back to the US, they wouldn't let him in, saying his history shows
his
    > propensity to stay in the US for more than 6 months, when he is not
allowed
    > to, and he had no return ticket to Canada to prove he was going to come
back
    > (to Canada). He's pissed off (it's his own fault, I know), and now says
he
    > can probably get this all cleared up by going to an immigration judge.
    > What are the chances they'll let him back into the US? I told him to give
    > it up, stay here, where he's from, and where he can actually work, but he
    > seems to think the US immigration judge will let him go back.
    > So, my questions:
    > What are the chances they'll let him back in? What are the chances he'll
    > even get a green card ever again?
    > Thank you!